J&J Slumps on $4.7 Billion Award to Cancer Patients

Women Claimed Johnson & Johnson's Talc Powder Gave Them Cancer. They Just Won $4.7 Billion in Damages

Women Claimed Johnson & Johnson's Talc Powder Gave Them Cancer. They Just Won $4.7 Billion in Damages

The award was earmarked for 22 women and their families who claimed Johnson & Johnson talcum powder products also contained asbestos.

A jury in a Missouri circuit court awarded $4.14 billion in punitive damages and $550 million in compensatory damages to the women, who had accused the company of failing to warn them about cancer risks associated with its baby and body powders.

The company now faces about 9,000 talc-cancer cases in state and federal court, according to published reports, with the bulk of state court cases in Missouri, New Jersey, and California, according to J&J's May 2018 quarterly report. The company has had previous success in overturning large verdicts in talc cases as well as others alleging harm from its products.

Johnson & Johnson called the ruling "fundamentally unfair" and has said it plans to appeal. "The multiple errors present in this trial were worse than those in the prior trials which have been reversed".

The plaintiffs' lawyers said asbestos fibers and talc particles were found in the ovarian tissues of numerous women.

According to the Los Angeles Times, it was alleged during the trial that Johnson & Johnson has covered up asbestos in their products for over 40 years.

The jury's decision that J&J's baby powder caused ovarian cancer could be more significant in the long-run then the large payout, as its stock dropped 1.4% after Thursday's verdict against its renowned product.

"J&J has strong arguments, but unless they get to certify this case to the U.S. Supreme Court, which are very long odds, this decision is likely to stand", said Lars Noah, a law professor at the University of Florida.




A jury ruled in Johnson & Johnson's favor in one lawsuit in California last November. The company has faced legal challenges on the same issue before, which it is still appealing or contesting.

Under the Supreme Court guidelines the $4 billion punitive award in St. Louis would likely be considered "excessive", said Anthony Sabino, law professor at St. John's University in NY. J&J sought to protect the image of Baby Powder as "their sacred cow", he said. "Johnson & Johnson remains confident that its products do not contain asbestos and do not cause ovarian cancer", J&J said in a statement. However, the prosecution in this case argued that J&J and the FDA's tests were flawed.

A separate but related set of lawsuits suggest Johnson & Johnson's powder is contaminated with asbestos.

Six of the women in the case have passed away and were represented at the trial by spouses and family members.

In other appeals, J&J convinced judges to toss verdicts worth $72 million and $55 million; appeals on the other cases are pending.

United Kingdom-based cancer charity Ovacome has said that there have been concerns for some years that using talcum powder on the genital area may increase the risk of ovarian cancer, but says this has not been proven by research.

Punitive damages are additional punishments levied against a defendant to prevent similar actions in the future.

Recommended News

  • British-US trade deal possible after Brexit, say May and Trump

    British-US trade deal possible after Brexit, say May and Trump

    Later in the press conference , Trump slammed reporter Kristen Welker after a question about Russian Federation . I'm sorry, I was wrong to say the things that I said would be an apology.
    Government Won’t Reunite All Under-5 Children With Parents Before Tuesday Deadline

    Government Won’t Reunite All Under-5 Children With Parents Before Tuesday Deadline

    The judge additionally asked for an update from the government on the reunification process by Thursday, Bloomberg reported . They will be set free in the U.S. pending the outcome of their immigration cases, which can take several years.
    Wimbledon: Halep bows out, Djokovic, Nadal move on

    Wimbledon: Halep bows out, Djokovic, Nadal move on

    World No.1 Simona Halep called her own performance "unprofessional" after she crashed out of Wimbledon . Hsieh, a former Wimbledon doubles champion, has never reached the quarter-finals of a Grand Slam.
  • House Committees Will Interview Lisa Page This Week

    House Committees Will Interview Lisa Page This Week

    It was then that he heard the news that she may defy the subpoena and refuse to testify and condemned it as a "total disgrace". The report did not find that the conclusions in the Clinton investigation were tainted by political bias.

    NBA Trade Grades: Hawks acquiring Jeremy Lin from Nets

    Lin, 29, played in only one game last season with Brooklyn, sustaining a season-ending ruptured patellar tendon on opening night. During a partially healthy season in Brooklyn during the 2016-17 season, Lin averaged 14.5 points and 5.1 assists over 36 games.
    Celebrities say England team did country proud after semi-final defeat

    Celebrities say England team did country proud after semi-final defeat

    Ten years ago we had a famous generation and now we are close to them because we are in the semi-final after 20 years. Luka Modric and Ivan Rakitic have shone brightly for their team and will hope to continue doing so.
  • Russian cargo ship delivers fuel, food for International Space Station

    The success of this mission may set the way for future Russian cargo and crew launches using the same expedited capability. This will be replaced with the new Multipurpose Laboratory Module Nauka, whose launch date is yet to be decided.
    Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh got into debt buying Nationals tickets

    Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh got into debt buying Nationals tickets

    Dana Loesch slammed Democrats for "shameless fearmongering" about President Donald Trump's Supreme Court pick. Wade to be overturned, but he hasn't discussed the issue with Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh .
    Prince Harry and Meghan visit Republic of Ireland

    Prince Harry and Meghan visit Republic of Ireland

    Proud parents the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge made their way into the service in London with their three children. Prince Louis , the youngest son of the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge , has been christened in a private ceremony.
  • World’s longest fingernails finally cut after 66 years

    World’s longest fingernails finally cut after 66 years

    No word on how Chillal is adapting to the lighter load on his left hand, but life just became easier for him in many ways. He said decades of dealing with the weight of his nails has left his hand permanently unable to open or move his fingers.
    Ronaldo's career in 60 seconds as Juventus move confirmed

    Ronaldo's career in 60 seconds as Juventus move confirmed

    These years in Real Madrid , and in this city of Madrid, have been possibly the happiest of my life. Madrid's current options for the attack are 28-year-old Gareth Bale and 30-year-old Karim Benzema .
    Whole Foods gets in on Amazon Prime Day deals too

    Whole Foods gets in on Amazon Prime Day deals too

    It's worth remembering that to get the deals you'll need an Amazon Prime account which costs £7.99 per month or £79 per year. At the Amazon Prime Day sale, the smartphones will come with an additional Rs 3000 off on the listed exchange price.

We are pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news.
Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper.
Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.