Apple Fined $9 Million Over 'Error 53' Backlash

Josh Miller  CNET

Josh Miller CNET

Apple has been fined AUS$9 million ($6.6 million/£5 million) for misleading Australian consumers about their right to get faulty iPhone and iPad devices repaired.

In April 2017, the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) commenced a legal battle with Apple in the Federal Court of Australia.

When Apple was told about the ACCC's investigation it started an outreach program to compensate consumers affected by error 53, which was extended to about 5000 customers.

The "error 53" disabled some iPhones and iPads after consumers updated Apple's iOS operating system.

Apple has stated on its website that if you have your device repaired by an unauthorised third party, it will not help if something goes wrong - such as error 53.

In addition to the $9 million fine, Apple offered a "court enforceable undertaking to not in engage in this kind of conduct in the future".




Prior to the update, several iPhone and iPad users turned to third party repair shops to fix a problem with Touch ID, and these places used non-Apple repairmen and components to repair disabled units.

"The Court declared the mere fact that an iPhone or iPad had been repaired by someone other than Apple did not, and could not, result in the consumer guarantees ceasing to apply, or the consumer's right to a remedy being extinguished".

The consumer watchdog said Apple had also committed to providing new devices as replacements, after allegations that the company was giving customers refurbished goods instead after a device suffered a major failure. "If customers would prefer a replacement, they are entitled to a new device as opposed to refurbished, if one is available", Court said.

She said multi-national firms and their returns policies had to be compliant with the Australian Consumer Law.

A company spokeswoman told Reuters it had had "very productive conversations with the ACCC about this" but declined to comment further on the court finding. Apple's Australian arm also said that it would improve training of its staff, post information about its warranties and Australian Consumer Law on its web site, and improve systems and compliance with the consumer laws in the the country.

Recommended News

  • James Comey made ‘error of judgement’ in Hillary Clinton probe

    James Comey made ‘error of judgement’ in Hillary Clinton probe

    He tweeted Friday he did a "great service to the people" in terminating Comey. Sessions spoke at Lackawanna College in Scranton, Pennsylvania.

    Phil Mickelson moving ball: Twitter goes wild US Open mistake

    Mickelson's shocking display in the third round earned him a two-stroke penalty and led to a 10 on the hole, an 81 overall. The two players shared a laugh after the freaky turn of events and Johnston later said he's never seen anything like it.
    Cristiano Ronaldo to pay £16.5m fine after tax fraud case

    Cristiano Ronaldo to pay £16.5m fine after tax fraud case

    The Real Madrid club-record goalscorer scored in Germany 2006 against Iran, in 2010 against North Korea and in 2014 against Ghana. The hat trick was Ronaldo's 84th goal for Portugal , tying him with Ferenc Puskas for most global goals by an European player.
  • Kanye West, Diplo, and more stars react to rapper XXXTentacion's sudden death

    Kanye West, Diplo, and more stars react to rapper XXXTentacion's sudden death

    Fans were apparently unswayed by - or attracted to - the star's tribulations; sending his latest album? to number one in the US. The shooting reportedly occurred just before 4:00 p.m. outside a Riva Motorsports location.
    Mexico - World Cup - 17 June 2018

    Mexico - World Cup - 17 June 2018

    The Germans open with a fully healthy squad, including star goalkeeper Manuel Neuer , who has recovered from a broken foot. Mexico were relentless at the back, however, and broke downfield on many occasions without success.
    Rescue boat carrying over 900 migrants docks in Italy

    Rescue boat carrying over 900 migrants docks in Italy

    On Wednesday, she said discussions between Italy, Germany and Austria were about finding "a Europe-wide solution". Under EU rules, migrants must apply for asylum in the European country where they first arrive.
  • Philippe Coutinho stunner cancelled by Steven Zuber as Brazil held 1-1

    Philippe Coutinho stunner cancelled by Steven Zuber as Brazil held 1-1

    They didn't look dominant during this match - and the talismanic Neymar didn't look entirely fit most of the time. Philippe Coutinho gave Brazil the lead in the 20th minute with a volley that bounced in off the right post.
    Rashford set to return to England training

    Rashford set to return to England training

    England's young guns are talking about emulating Andres Iniesta and Dani Alves but four years ago they watched the World Cup on the back of spells at Burnley, Brighton, Carlisle and York.
    Trump Mocked After Lauding North Korea's Real Estate Potential

    Trump Mocked After Lauding North Korea's Real Estate Potential

    In a post-summit interview with ABC News, the president said he was confident that the agreement meant full denuclearisation. He pointed out the real estate potential of its "great beaches" which can be seen on missile test footage.
  • Eight injured after taxi runs into crowd in Moscow

    Eight injured after taxi runs into crowd in Moscow

    The authority cited the driver, who was in police custody, as saying he had not driven into the crowd on objective . Mexico's embassy in Russian Federation said two of its citizens were among the injured.
    How To Watch The Matches Online And On TV

    How To Watch The Matches Online And On TV

    The event brings one of the most exceptional football players into one place, and you get a chance to cheer your favorite teams . Some may involve paying for access, or for VPNs, some might be from shady sources, and some won't be easy.
    Cuper: Mo Salah should be fine to face Russian Federation

    Cuper: Mo Salah should be fine to face Russian Federation

    Defender Jose Gimenez was the unlikely 89th-minute match victor for Tabarez's men, who also struck a post late on through Edinson Cavani.

We are pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news.
Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper.
Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.