Supreme Court Sides With Baker Who Turned Away Gay Couple

Masterpiece Cakeshop owner Jack Phillips cracks eggs into a cake batter mixer inside his store in Lakewood Colo. The Supreme Court is taking on a new clash between gay rights and religion in a case about a weddin

Masterpiece Cakeshop owner Jack Phillips cracks eggs into a cake batter mixer inside his store in Lakewood Colo. The Supreme Court is taking on a new clash between gay rights and religion in a case about a weddin

Its staff demonstrated a "clear and impermissible hostility toward the honest religious" and did not make efforts to accommodate the religious freedom of the business owners.

The case pitted Phillips' First Amendment claims of artistic freedom against the anti-discrimination arguments of the Colorado commission, and the two men Phillips turned away in 2012.

But they did not definitively rule on the issue of whether a business can decline to serve gays and lesbians based on religious views, meaning the broader contentious issue is likely to simmer.

Kennedy wrote that the question of when religious beliefs must give way to anti-discrimination laws might be different in future cases.

Phillips was sanctioned by the state civil rights commission after a formal complaint from the couple.

Rather, the court found that the Colorado Civil Rights Commission had acted improperly when it said that the owner of the Masterpiece Cakeshop in suburban Denver could not refuse to make a same-sex wedding cake because the body "showed elements of a clear and impermissible hostility toward the honest religious beliefs motivating his objection", and therefore did not act with "the requisite religious neutrality". Justice Neil Gorsuch and Justice Samuel Alito co-wrote their concurring opinions. In their decision posted on Monday, the justices ruled the Colorado Civil Rights Commission didn't maintain religious neutrality when it ruled against Phillips.




President Donald Trump's administration intervened in support of the baker.

In the wake of the marriage ruling, conservative religious-rights advocates led by the Alliance Defending Freedom sought to establish a right to refuse to help celebrate a same-sex marriage. "There is much in the court's opinion with which I agree", Ginsburg wrote of Kennedy's repeated references to protecting the rights of gay people.

For the baker's supporters, the case was about finding a way to respect conflicting beliefs about marriage. At the time, Colorado did not recognize the validity of gay marriages, however, and the U.S. Supreme Court had not yet found a constitutional right for gays to marry.

"Phillips would not sell to Craig and Mullins, for no reason other than their sexual orientation, a cake of the kind he regularly sold to others", Ginsburg said. "The proceedings involved several layers of independent decision-making, of which the commission was but one". The Arizona-based group brought suits on a behalf of a wedding photographer in New Mexico, a florist in Washington state and the Colorado baker whose case reached the Supreme Court.

Read the court's complete opinion at supremecourt.gov, with the majority opinion written by Kennedy. "It's hard to see the decision setting a precedent".

"There is an intentional campaign out there of people who are opposed to LGBT rights but also to equality more broadly", he said.

Recommended News

  • WWDC 18: Watch Apple map out the future of iOS and macOS

    WWDC 18: Watch Apple map out the future of iOS and macOS

    Secondly, iOS 12 and Safari is going to make it much, much harder for third parties to track you across the internet. Apple is expected to launch an exciting new iPhone feature to address a problem it helped create: phone addiction.
    What Analysts are hoping about Apple Inc. (NASDAQ:AAPL)'s WWDC event?

    What Analysts are hoping about Apple Inc. (NASDAQ:AAPL)'s WWDC event?

    This might be great news for fans of the Pokemon Go AR game, who are still waiting for player-versus-player battle features. The macOS, meanwhile, is expected to get a new dark theme, along with a host of other user-friendly features.
    Merkel rules out relief for Italy

    Merkel rules out relief for Italy

    Merkel also backs the step-by-step introduction of a euro zone investment budget in the low double-digit billions of euros. She said the initiative should bring down the number of different European Union weapon systems from 180 to "about 30".
  • Spanish PM Mariano Rajoy ousted after failing confidence motion

    Spanish PM Mariano Rajoy ousted after failing confidence motion

    Sanchez backed Rajoy on his firm line in defense of the Spanish constitution, which doesn't permit regions to break away. The report notes that Rajoy's ouster by parliament is a first for a serving leader in four decades of Spanish democracy.
    Fallout Vault 76, What to Expect and When to Expect it

    Fallout Vault 76, What to Expect and When to Expect it

    It's worth noting that the majority of games Bethesda featured during its E3 2017 conference were released later that year. The thing that struck us most was the casual announcement of an already complete "Making Of" documentary for Fallout 76 .
    Apple will use WWDC 2018 to tackle iPhone addiction and iOS bugs

    Apple will use WWDC 2018 to tackle iPhone addiction and iOS bugs

    HomePod Apple is not coming slow! To catch up to Amazon and Google's digital speakers, Apple will have to improve Siri . Google recently unveiled its own suite of " digital wellbeing " tools for its new Android P operating system.
  • Before World Cup, another injury fear for Belgium’s Kompany

    Before World Cup, another injury fear for Belgium’s Kompany

    The Manchester City captain sustained what is thought to be a groin injury during the 0-0 draw at King Baudouin Stadium. The defender was forced to miss Euro 2016 after picking up a thigh injury in the Champions League semifinal that May.
    The summit's back on: Trump meets N. Korean at White House

    The summit's back on: Trump meets N. Korean at White House

    Despite recently envisioning Nobel laurels, Trump worked on Friday to lower expectations for a quick breakthrough. Questions remain about what a deal on the North's nuclear weapons would look like.

    Bryan Colangelo already losing trust from players around National Basketball Association

    The accounts were also very defensive of Colangelo's decision-making, and even his choice in dress shirts. Vince Quinn of SportsRadio 94WIP says the Sixers have no choice but to fire him.
  • Pacific deal focuses on S. China Sea status

    Pacific deal focuses on S. China Sea status

    Mattis responded that the question reflected a fundamental disconnect with the way global tribunals have spoken on the matter. Mr Mattis also touched on Taiwan, a longstanding dispute between the USA and China.
    Sears' latest closings include Fox Valley store

    Sears' latest closings include Fox Valley store

    It also closed its stores in the Southpark Mall in Colonial Heights in January and in Regency mall in Henrico County in September. He's the retailer's biggest shareholder and has been using his own money for years to keep the 125-year-old chain open.
    Hawaii volcano eruption shoots lava fountain 200 feet into the sky

    Hawaii volcano eruption shoots lava fountain 200 feet into the sky

    Leilani Estates resident Steve Gebbie said he lost his home to lava Sunday night. "Donna's house is gone". Pele's hair is sharp, thin strands of volcanic glass fibers.

We are pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news.
Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper.
Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.